If you have approved a 401(k) audit in the last few years, you may have been asked to elect a “limited-scope” or “full-scope” engagement without much explanation of what the choice actually meant. For most HR directors, CFOs and plan administrators, an engagement letter or management acknowledgment arrives, gets signed and the audit proceeds. Then a question comes up later, often from a CFO, legal counsel or the plan’s financial advisor, and the answer is not obvious.
This post explains what each option covers, when the ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) election is available, and what your auditor’s report will actually opine on under each approach. It also explains why the term “limited-scope” is now out of date: since the AICPA auditing standard SAS No. 136 took effect, these engagements are formally called ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audits, and the report no longer includes a disclaimer of opinion. It is written for plan sponsors, and the advisors who support them, who deserve a straight answer rather than a definition dump.
| QUICK ANSWER: A 401(k) audit can be performed as a full-scope audit or, if the plan administrator elects it, as an ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit, formerly called a limited-scope audit. The election only affects investment information that a qualified institution, such as a regulated bank, trust company or insurance carrier, has certified as accurate and complete. The auditor does not audit that certified information, but still tests contributions, distributions, participant data and plan compliance, among other areas, using risk-based procedures. Under SAS No. 136, the auditor’s report contains a two-part opinion rather than a disclaimer of opinion. |
What Does a 401(k) Audit Actually Cover?
A 401(k) audit is an independent examination of the plan’s financial statements, performed by an independent qualified public accountant in accordance with ERISA, DOL reporting rules and AICPA auditing standards. Whether the engagement is full-scope or a 103(a)(3)(C) audit, the auditor uses risk-based procedures to test areas such as:
- Employer and employee contributions, including timeliness of remittances
- Participant distributions, loans and hardship withdrawals
- Allocations of contributions, earnings and forfeitures to participant accounts
- Plan document compliance, including eligibility, vesting and the definition of compensation
- Participant data and recordkeeping accuracy
- Notes to the financial statements and required ERISA disclosures
The election affects one specific area, the auditor’s work on certified investment information. Everything else is audited regardless of which approach the plan takes.
What Is the ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) Election?
A limited-scope 401(k) audit, now called an ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit, is not a reduced-quality audit. It is a statutory option under ERISA that removes the requirement to audit certified investment information, while contributions, distributions, allocations and plan document compliance are still tested.
The ERISA section 103 audit election allows the plan administrator to instruct the auditor not to audit investment information prepared and certified by a qualified institution. Under the DOL regulation at 29 CFR 2520.103-8, that institution must be a bank or similar institution, or an insurance carrier, that is regulated, supervised and subject to periodic examination by a state or federal agency. The certification must cover both the accuracy and the completeness of the investment information.
This is a legal provision written into ERISA, not an auditor’s preference or a shortcut. It reflects the fact that the institutions eligible to certify are already subject to their own regulatory supervision and examination.
The election is the plan administrator’s decision, not the auditor’s. Under SAS No. 136, plan management must also acknowledge in writing that it has determined the 103(a)(3)(C) audit is permissible and that the certification meets the regulatory requirements. The auditor evaluates management’s assessment and the certification as part of the engagement, then performs the audit under the approach management has elected.
How Does a Full-Scope 401(k) Audit Differ in Practice?
In a limited-scope plan audit under 103(a)(3)(C), the auditor does not audit the certified investment information, although it still performs specific procedures on it. These include comparing the certified information to the plan’s financial statements and evaluating whether the related disclosures are consistent with the certification and presented in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework. Under full scope, the auditor tests that investment information directly using risk-based procedures. The full-scope 401(k) audit differences matter most in three areas: testing procedures, the auditor’s report, and cost and timeline.
| Audit Area | 103(a)(3)(C) Audit (Formerly Limited-Scope) | Full-Scope Audit |
|---|---|---|
| Contributions | Tested using risk-based procedures | Tested using risk-based procedures |
| Distributions and loans | Tested using risk-based procedures | Tested using risk-based procedures |
| Allocations and participant data | Tested using risk-based procedures | Tested using risk-based procedures |
| Plan document compliance | Tested using risk-based procedures | Tested using risk-based procedures |
| Certified investment information, including investment income | Not audited. Compared to the certification, with related disclosures evaluated | Audited using risk-based procedures |
| Investment information not covered by a certification | Audited using risk-based procedures | Audited using risk-based procedures |
| Auditor’s opinion | Two-part opinion (no disclaimer) | Opinion on the financial statements as a whole |
The 401(k) audit cost and timeline implications are real. Full-scope engagements involve additional procedures on the investment side, which generally means more time and higher fees. The exact difference depends on plan size, investment types and how well organized the plan’s records are.
How Does the 401(k) Audit Report Change Under Each Approach?
This is the section most articles skip, and it is often the one that matters most when the DOL or a plan fiduciary reviews the filing.
Under SAS No. 136, a 103(a)(3)(C) audit report no longer includes a disclaimer of opinion. Instead, the auditor issues a two-part opinion covering the information that was audited and the certified investment information.
The first part addresses whether the amounts and disclosures not covered by the certification are presented fairly, in all material respects, in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework. The second part addresses whether the certified investment information in the financial statements agrees with, or is derived from, the certification. The report also explains that the plan administrator elected the 103(a)(3)(C) audit, which is why the certified investment information was not audited.
Many older reports, and many articles still online, describe a disclaimer of opinion. That format applied before SAS No. 136, which is effective for plan audits of periods ending on or after December 15, 2021. Under a full-scope audit, the auditor’s opinion covers the financial statements as a whole, including the investment information.
Both report forms are recognized under ERISA and current auditing standards, and either one is attached to the plan’s Form 5500 filing. A 103(a)(3)(C) report is appropriate when the election is permissible for the plan and supported by a qualifying certification. For the filing calendar itself, see our guide to the Form 5500 due date and filing timeline.
Do the 103(a)(3)(C) Rules Differ by State?
No. Because ERISA is a federal law, the election, the certification requirements and the audit reporting rules are the same in every state, and plans of all sizes use the election when their assets are held by qualified institutions such as banks, trust companies and insurance carriers. What does vary is the institution. Certification practices differ from one trustee or custodian to the next, and a recordkeeper that is not itself a qualified institution cannot provide the certification. Whether a plan is based in Boston or San Diego, the useful question is the same: is our current audit approach appropriate for how our plan is structured?
How Should Plan Sponsors Approach the Scope Decision?
Whether your plan can use the 103(a)(3)(C) election depends on the facts of the specific plan, not a default assumption. Before the audit begins, confirm with the trustee or custodian holding plan assets that it is a qualified institution and that it will provide a certification covering both the accuracy and completeness of the investment information. If a certification is not available, or does not meet the regulatory requirements, the investment information it would have covered must be audited in full.
Whether a plan is eligible for the 103(a)(3)(C) election depends on the facts of the specific plan and the certification provided by the qualified institution. It is not a default assumption, and it should be confirmed before each audit cycle.
Picture a plan sponsor that changed recordkeepers partway through the year and assumed the election would carry over automatically. The new platform holds assets with a separate trust company, so the certification has to come from that custodian, and the old provider still needs to certify the months before the change. Confirming who will issue each certification, and that together they cover the full plan year, before fieldwork begins avoids a late discovery that part of the investment information has to be audited in full.
For advisors, the scope election is worth raising with plan sponsor clients ahead of each audit cycle. Asking whether the certification has been confirmed, and who signed the management acknowledgment, helps the sponsor understand a decision that is theirs to make.
For a fuller view of what a well-run audit process looks like from the plan sponsor’s side, our guide on preparing for the 401(k) audit process walks through the practical steps to have ready before the auditor begins fieldwork. If you want to understand how plan management determines whether the election is available, our article on determining whether an ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit is permissible covers the criteria, and the AICPA’s plan advisory on ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audits is written specifically for plan management.
Key Takeaways
- A 401(k) audit can be full-scope or, if the plan administrator elects it, an ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit, formerly called a limited-scope audit.
- The election only affects investment information certified as accurate and complete by a qualified institution such as a regulated bank, trust company or insurance carrier.
- Contributions, distributions, allocations, participant data and plan document compliance are tested under both approaches using risk-based procedures.
- Under SAS No. 136, a 103(a)(3)(C) audit report contains a two-part opinion rather than a disclaimer of opinion.
- Plan management must acknowledge in writing that the election is permissible, and the certification should be confirmed before each audit cycle.
- Full-scope audits generally take more time and cost more because of the additional investment testing.
The Bottom Line: Confirm Your 401(k) Audit Approach Before the Next Cycle
If you are not certain whether your plan’s last 401(k) audit was performed under the right approach, or whether the 103(a)(3)(C) election was supported by a qualifying certification, the time to ask is before your next audit cycle begins rather than after the Form 5500 is filed. Understanding the difference between a full-scope and a 103(a)(3)(C) audit helps plan sponsors, and the advisors who support them, make that decision with a clear picture of what each option involves.
Caron Bletzer is a national CPA firm that works exclusively on employee benefit plan audits, including 401(k), 403(b) and other defined contribution plans, defined benefit, ESOP and health and welfare plans, and is a member of the AICPA Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center. If you are already reviewing audit firms for this year’s audit, you can request a proposal at any time.
Reviewed by Kimberly Jarry, CPA, Partner. Kimberly has concentrated her practice on employee benefit plan audits for more than 13 years, and is a licensed CPA in New Hampshire.
Questions Plan Sponsors Ask About 401(k) Audit Scope
What is a limited-scope 401(k) audit?
A limited-scope audit, now formally called an ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit, is a 401(k) audit in which the auditor does not audit investment information certified by a qualified institution such as a regulated bank, trust company or insurance carrier. The auditor still tests contributions, distributions, allocations and plan document compliance using risk-based procedures. The change in name came with SAS No. 136, which also replaced the old disclaimer of opinion with a two-part opinion.
What does the 103(a)(3)(C) election mean for plan sponsors?
It is the plan administrator’s decision to have the audit performed under ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C). To use it, the plan’s investments must be held by a qualified institution that certifies the information as accurate and complete, and management must acknowledge in writing that the election is permissible. The auditor then does not audit the certified investment information, but compares it with the certification and evaluates the related disclosures.
Is a limited-scope audit less thorough than a full-scope audit?
Not across the board. A 103(a)(3)(C) audit applies the same risk-based approach as a full-scope audit to everything outside the certified investment information. The difference lies in how the auditor treats certified investments, not in the standards applied to the rest of the audit. When the election is permissible and properly supported, it is a recognized way to meet the plan’s audit requirement.
What does the auditor’s report say differently under a 103(a)(3)(C) audit?
Under current standards, the report contains a two-part opinion: one on the information not covered by the certification, and one on whether the certified investment information agrees with, or is derived from, the certification. Reports issued before SAS No. 136 contained a disclaimer of opinion, which is why some older articles still describe it that way. A full-scope report contains an opinion on the financial statements as a whole.
Can any 401(k) plan use the limited-scope election?
No. The election is only available for investment information held and certified by a qualified institution that certifies its accuracy and completeness. If the institution holding the assets does not qualify, or the certification does not meet DOL requirements, that investment information must be audited in full. Plan management is responsible for making this determination.
How does a full-scope 401(k) audit differ in cost and timeline?
Full-scope audits involve additional procedures to test investment information directly, which generally means more time and higher cost than a 103(a)(3)(C) audit. The specific difference depends on the plan’s size, complexity and the investment types involved. An organized document process and early engagement with the auditor support a timely completion under either approach.
Does a 401(k) audit test every transaction?
No. Under either approach, the auditor uses risk-based testing procedures rather than examining every transaction. An audit provides independent assurance based on applicable auditing standards, and it is not a guarantee that every operational or compliance issue has been identified.